A Clean and Simple Picture Perfect Birthday Pop Out Swing card

So some people don't like to see a card smothered with a load of papers...

So I thought I would remake a recent Fancy Fold card I have shared... but somewhat more in the nude! AKA clean & simple in style with lots of white....

Here are the 2 together...

And here is the link to the first one with Tutorial details...

So which one do you prefer?

And which one do you think I prefer??

Answers in comments - or just click here if you are you feeling more shy (and prefer to email)

SU! Products Used
Picture Perfect Birthday stamps
Inks- Lemon Lime Twist, Bermuda Bay, Pool Party, Peekaboo Peach